189 Highfield Lane, Nutley, NJ — front exterior of the renovated Queen Anne Victorian

Nutley, New Jersey

189 Highfield Lane

Explore the Residence

A Queen Anne Victorian,
Rebuilt From the Studs

Built in 1900 and fully gutted and rebuilt in 2021, 189 Highfield Lane pairs a historic frame with entirely new systems. At just over 5,200 square feet, wide-plank hardwood floors and LED lighting carry a bright, cohesive flow through five bedrooms and four and a half baths.

The Residence →
5 Bedrooms
4 Full & 1 Half Baths
5,200 Square Feet
$1,799,000

Rooms Built
Around an Open Flow

An open expanse joins the living room, dining room, and kitchen into one gathering space. A home office and finished basement bring everyday ease to grand-scale living.

View Full Gallery →

Property Highlights

Six defining features of a Victorian rebuilt from the ground up.

Complete 2021 Renovation

Fully gutted and rebuilt with new wiring, plumbing, flooring, walls, windows, doors, and insulation — a historic frame given new bones from top to bottom.

Rebuilt Saltwater Pool

The heated saltwater pool has been fully rebuilt with new filters, heater, liner, electrical, and plumbing.

Patio & Fenced Yard

A patio extends the living space outdoors, and the backyard is fully fenced for privacy and peace of mind.

Guest Suite

A guest suite with its own bathroom offers separate living space for visitors or extended family.

Two-Car Garage

An attached two-car garage with 16-foot ceilings suits both car enthusiasts and hobbyists.

Modern Systems Throughout

A brand-new roof, smart thermostats, a 3-zone HVAC system, and a tankless hot water heater make for quiet, efficient living.

A Pool, a Patio,
and Room to Breathe

The saltwater pool anchors a fenced backyard, with a patio extending the living space outdoors. A nine-zone programmable smart irrigation system keeps the grounds pristine, with pre-wiring in place for outdoor cameras.

Lot Size 0.46 Acres
Year Built 1900 · Renov. 2021
Rooms 10
Garage 2-Car Attached
See the Grounds →
rebuilt saltwater pool and fenced backyard at 189 Highfield Lane

Nutley,
New Jersey

189 Highfield Lane sits on one of Nutley's most established streets, close to downtown and top-rated schools. Direct rail service to New York City is five minutes away.

0.46 acres on a 100-by-200-foot lot in Nutley Township, Essex County — Block 4002, Lot 12. The backyard is fully fenced, with a nine-zone smart irrigation system across the grounds.

Built in 1900 in the Queen Anne Victorian style and fully renovated in 2021 with a complete gut renovation, including a new roof and all-new wiring, plumbing, flooring, windows, and doors. The home totals 5,200 square feet across ten rooms.

A 3-zone gas forced-air heating system and 3-zone central air, a tankless hot water heater, and smart thermostats throughout. Public water and sewer, with all utilities underground.

2025 annual taxes of $29,114 on a total assessment of $1,078,700. Assigned to Yantacaw grade school and Nutley High School.

Downloads

Property materials are released to qualified buyers and their representatives. Submit a brief request and our listing team will respond directly.

Survey & Lot Plan

0.46 acres · Available on request

Request

Floor Plans

5,200 square feet · Available on request

Request

Feature Sheet

Full specification · Available on request

Request

Tax & Assessment Detail

2025 taxes $29,114 · Available on request

Request
New Jersey Luxury Real Estate Group · Powered By SERHANT.

Exclusively listed by The NJ Luxury Real Estate Group, in partnership with SERHANT. — the most followed real estate brand in the world.

Arrange a Private Showing

Complete the form below and your inquiry will open in your email client, addressed to our listing team.

Your information is kept strictly confidential.